Alaska votes Tues. on instant runoff voting -- you can help
instantrunoff instantrunoff at yahoo.com
Fri, 23 Aug 2002 23:06:37 -0000
Alaska instant runoff voting election edition of
Midwest Democracy Center's electoral reform news
Compiled by Dan Johnson-Weinberger, djw@fairvote.org, 312.587.7060
The Midwest Democracy Center is a non-profit, membership advocacy
group that works to make our governments more democratic and
representative. We partner with the D.C.-based Center for Voting and
Democracy (www.fairvote.org).
Our main goal is to revive cumulative voting for the Illinois House
of Representatives (used from 1870 ? 1980) so that political
minorities will have some representation. Electing three people from
one big district instead of three people each elected from their own
smaller district ensures that all voters have someone who represents
their views, wherever they happen to live, and lessens the number of
one-party fiefdoms.
Our other goal is to use instant runoff voting for single-winner
elections (like governor) especially in primary elections to ensure
the majority of voters gets to pick the winner.
Our website is www.midwestdemocracy.org and our telephone number is
312.587.7060. We encourage your participation and membership! Join
online by clicking here:
https://www.paypal.com/xclick/business=xx817%40prairienet.org
ALASKA TO VOTE ON INSTANT RUNOFF VOTING TUESDAY
your help needed to pass this fantastic reform
The most exciting campaign of the summer for electoral reformers is
happening on Tuesday, August 27th, when Alaskans will vote on whether
to implement instant runoff voting for all federal races and most
state races. Instant runoff voting gives voters more power as it lets
voters rank candidates (1, 2, 3) instead of just settling for one. It
requires candidates to earn a majority of votes (50% + 1) instead of
slipping by with 36% (like Rod Blagojevich in the Democratic
primary).
Measure 1, as it is called, would apply to the presidential race as
well, making Alaska the first state to use instant runoff voting to
select their federal officeholders. This is a breakthrough campaign ?
if we win.
If you would like to support the campaign in Alaska, the best thing
you can do is to call 10 voters in Alaska. We will send you the names
and telephone numbers of 10 Alaskans who are very likely to vote on
Tuesday. You call them, follow the script that we send you, and help
convince them to vote Yes on Measure 1.
It's easy but crucial.
We are also phone banking from the Midwest Democracy Center (325 West
Huron #304) on Sunday from 4 pm to 7 pm and again from 10 pm to
midnight, Monday from 9 pm to midnight and Tuesday, the 27th, we're
having a victory party from 10 pm to whenever the last person leaves.
If you can help phone bank, please bring a cell phone if you have one
with free long distance. If not, just come by.
If you can not phone bank in the Chicago office, please email me at
djw@fairvote.org and I will send you a list of 10 names and numbers
to call with the script.
This is the most important way we can convince people, one at a time,
to vote for instant runoff voting. If you can spare one hour this
weekend or Monday night (call until midnight CST, as Alaska is three
hours behind Illinois time), please do so and call 10 voters in
Alaska. Email me at djw@fairvote.org and I will send you those names
and numbers.
The campaign website is www.AlaskansForVotersRights.com and we expect
to win.
Keep your eyes peeled for a story on the Alaska campaign in USA Today
Monday or Tuesday as well, as well as a potential story on CNN. You
can be a part of history! Email me at djw@fairvote.org to get those
10 names and numbers right now.
SPEAKING EVENT AUGUST 28th IN CHICAGO
Dan Johnson-Weinberger will speak about electoral reform thanks to
the Rolling Thunder Tour's Chicago coalition
(www.rollingthundertour.org). If you'd like to introduce a friend to
the drive to revive cumulative voting or hear about the victory in
Alaska, come on out. And bring a friend!
When: Wed. Aug. 28, 7:00-9:00pm (folks can arrive between 6:30 & 7:00)
Where: Healing Earth Resources, 3111 N. Ashland (S. of Belmont);
metered street parking & in Petco lot across the street; near CTA.
(See: www.healingearthresources.com)
COST: $5 suggested donation (to pay for the space)
NOTE: The room holds about 50 people, so you may want to get there
early!
CUMULATIVE VOTING AT IL MUNICIPAL LEAGUE CONFERENCE
September 14th at the Illinois Municipal League annual conference in
Chicago, we'll participate in a panel discussion on the drive to
revive cumulative voting from 10:15 am to 11:45 am. If you can attend
the conference, please do so. www.iml.org for more details. You don't
have to be an elected official to attend, and the more people that
can come and talk about cumulative voting, the more likely we are to
earn more support for the cause. It would be fantastic if the
Illinois Municipal League would endorse the drive to revive
cumulative voting, and workshops like this one are a great way to
begin that process.
ILLINOIS LEADER PRINTS OUR LETTER TO THE EDITOR
The Illinois Leader, a conservative-oriented website on Illinois
politics, printed a letter to the editor on the spoiler problem that
the Libertarians and Republicans face in Illinois this year. Thanks
to them for printing it; check it out at this link.
http://www.illinoisleader.com/letters/lettersview.asp?c=1614
I'll run the letter at the end of the newsletter as well.
INTERNS MOSTLY FINISH THEIR GOOD WORK, WE WANT MORE
How does the Midwest Democracy Center work? People invest time and
energy into it. This summer, we were lucky to have three solid
interns.
Mary Kennelly came in every Monday and worked primarily on research
on the Irish voting system. They use instant runoff voting to pick
their president and a cousin of cumulative voting (districts electing
three to five people) to pick their legislature so political
minorities are elected. You can see the fruits of her labor at
www.IrishVoting.org
Brian Smith came in two or three days a week and researched same-day
voter registration. He contacted officials from all six states that
have same-day voter registration and soon, a great website will be
launched that promotes the issue. Brian and Mary and both now back in
college.
Peter Snyder is our latest intern, and we're lucky that his college
doesn't start until mid-September. He's the web guru who put
www.IrishVoting.org together with Mary's content and has helped in
many other ways as well. And he's only 18!
We are now looking for a few good interns for the fall that want to
get to work making our government more representative and more
democratic. If you know of any students looking for an internship,
please send them our way. Many earn academic credit for their time
here, and we put them to good use (a minimum of busy work). Call me
at 312.587.7060 or email at djw@fairvote.org -- we are also looking
to speak on college campuses, so contact me and we can try to set up
a speaking engagement.
STATE CANDIDATE SURVEY MAILED THIS WEEK; COUNTY MAILING NEXT?
Thanks primarily to Hannah Podlevsky, we mailed out a candidate
survey to all 330 candidates for state office in Illinois, asking
them a dozen questions as to which political reforms they would
support.
We plan to post results on our website as they come in, but if you
know a candidate (or are a candidate), be sure to fill out the survey
or, alternatively, we can fax or email you another copy. We'd like to
get a high return rate and get a running start on our lobbying for
the January 2003 session of the General Assembly, so we can actually
pass some legislation.
Some intermediate steps in Springfield we are planning to push for
include:
*allowing all municipalities to use cumulative voting
*allowing all county boards to use cumulative voting
*allowing all municipalities to use instant runoff voting
*abolishing party appointment of vacancies in state or municipal
office in favor of special elections
*allowing counties to use touch-screen voting
And, of course, we are asking state candidates if they will vote to
put a constitutional amendment to bring back cumulative voting on the
November 2004 ballot, as well as implement instant runoff voting for
party primaries and the general election.
We are thinking about doing a survey of candidates for county board
in some of the 102 counties in Illinois, asking them if they support
using cumulative voting in their multi-member districts and if they
support a return to cumulative voting for the state House of
Representatives. If you are interested in helping to pull together a
survey of the candidates in your county, please email me at
djw@fairvote.org or call the office at 312.587.7060.
FULL TEXT OF LETTER IN ILLINOIS LEADER (illinosleader.com)
Hold Run-Off Elections to Eliminate Spoilers
Thursday, August 15, 2002
- Dan Johnson-Weinberger, Director, Midwest Democracy Center
Scrappy Illinois Libertarians have survived the Republican Party's
challenge to their 52,000+ signatures to appear on the November
statewide ballot, after the GOP -- quite smartly, given their
resources -- withdrew their objections last week. Almost immediately,
cries of spoilers are heard on the right side of the aisle.
This always happens: an energetic group of mavericks, driven by ideas
instead of patronage, works very hard to secure ballot access. And
once they do, their ideological allies turn on them, calling them
spoilers and repeating the mantra: a vote for the best helps to elect
the worst.
In other words, shut up and settle for the better of two uninspiring
parties.
This is a problem, and it is caused by our plurality voting system.
Because there is no requirement that the winner of an election earn a
majority of votes (50% + 1), spoilers exist. The majority of voters
can split their vote (between Jim Ryan and Cal Skinner in Illinois,
or Al Gore and Ralph Nader in Florida -- or for that matter, between
Paul Vallas and Roland Burris in the Democratic primary), allowing a
candidate to win with 40-some percent of the vote.
It's a terrible way to run an election, because new parties are great
for democracy. They bring in new ideas and energize new voters. How
can we encourage new parties to form and contest elections without
the Orwellian tranformation of their votes to help their worst enemy?
Hold a runoff.
It's that easy. A runoff election if no one earns a majority of the
ote eliminates the spoiler problem completely. If Ryan and
Blagojavich battle it out to 49 percent each with the Libertarians
earning the other 2 percent, it's not time to declare a winner. Knock
off the Libertarians and have the two old parties compete for the
majority vote. No more spoilers. Plus, all the disaffected
conservatives and libertarian-leaning Republicans can send their
message to the GOP machine and vote for the Libertarians in the first
round, confident that they can elect the chastened Republican in the
runoff.
Even better, look to the Utah Republican Party and use instant runoff
voting. That's the same process as a runoff election, but it lets
voters indicate who their runoff vote would go to if their favorite
candidate is eliminated -- in one election. Voters do this by ranking
the candidates (1, 2, 3). Count the first-choice votes first. If
someone has earned a majority of those votes, they win. If not, we
need to hold an instant runoff. Eliminate the candidate who came in
last, and look to the runoff votes of their supporters.
For Libertarian voters, we can assume that most of their second-
choice votes would be the Republicans. We add those on to the first-
choice votes of the surviving candidates -- just like a runoff
election where everyone picks between two candidates -- and see who
has earned the majority of votes. The Utah Republicans use this at
their state conventions, as several candidates vie for the party's
endorsement and they want to ensure the endorsed candidate has the
broadest amount of support -- and isn't an accidentlal winner due to
the majority splitting their vote.
Alaska faces this GOP spoiler problem and the Republican Party there
is doing something about it. They've placed on the August 27th
primary ballot an initiative -- Measure 1 -- to implement instant
runoff voting for all federal races. Faced with the Libertarian
Party, the Alaskan Independence Party and the Republican Moderate
Party (there is a such thing up there), the Republican Party
enthusiastically endorsed the initiative to end spoiler elections for
good.
Illinois should do the same and implement this modern voting system.
Thank you for reading; please forward this newsletter!
Midwest Democracy Center
325 West Huron #304
Chicago, IL 60610
312.587.7060
www.midwestdemocracy.org